Do I Really Need a Hip Replacement? Should I Get a Second Opinion?

You’ve been told you need a hip replacement—but now what?

It’s completely normal to feel uncertain. Hip replacement surgery is a big step, and you might be wondering:

Is this really necessary?
Are there other options I should try first?
Should I get a second opinion?

This blog will help you understand:

When surgery is truly the best option
Conservative treatments—do they still work at this stage?
Whether a second opinion is worth considering

Do I Really Need a Hip Replacement?

Your doctor has recommended surgery, but how do you know if it’s the right decision? A hip replacement is typically advised when:

1. You Have Severe, Ongoing Pain

If your hip pain doesn’t improve with pain relief, physiotherapy, or other treatments, and it disrupts your daily life—this is a major sign that surgery might be necessary.

2. Your Mobility Is Getting Worse

Struggling to walk, climb stairs, or even put on socks? A hip replacement can help restore your movement and independence.

3. X-Rays or MRI Show Severe Joint Damage

Your surgeon will have assessed your imaging results. If they show significant arthritis or joint deterioration, surgery is often the best long-term solution.

4. Other Treatments Are No Longer Helping

You may have already tried physiotherapy, pain medications, cortisone injections, or walking aids—but if these no longer provide relief, surgery may be the next step.

5. Your Quality of Life Is Suffering

Are you avoiding activities you once loved because of your hip pain? If your condition is stopping you from living life fully, it might be time to consider surgery.

Are There Other Options I Should Try First?

Before recommending surgery, most doctors will ensure you've exhausted all non-surgical options. But at this stage, are there still things you can try?

Here’s what to consider:

Physiotherapy – Strengthening surrounding muscles can help, but if your joint damage is severe, relief may be minimal.
Pain Medications – Anti-inflammatories and pain relievers might offer short-term relief, but they won’t fix the underlying issue.
Cortisone Injections – These can temporarily reduce inflammation, but their effectiveness decreases as arthritis progresses.
Lifestyle Adjustments – Walking aids, weight management, and low-impact exercises can help, but they may not be enough if the joint is too damaged.

If you’ve already tried these treatments without success, hip replacement may be the best long-term solution.

Should I Get a Second Opinion?

Even if you trust your doctor, getting a second opinion can provide clarity and confidence in your decision.

When to Consider a Second Opinion

If you want to ensure surgery is the right choice
If you’d like to explore different surgical techniques (e.g. minimally invasive options)
If you feel your questions weren’t fully answered in your first consultation
If you simply need peace of mind before making a big decision

Why a Second Opinion Can Be Helpful

Confirms Your Diagnosis – Another specialist can review your scans and symptoms to ensure surgery is the best option.
Explores Alternative Treatments – If there’s another option worth trying, a second doctor may suggest it.
Provides Surgical Options – Not all hip replacements are the same—different approaches may suit your lifestyle better.
Gives You Confidence – Knowing you’ve fully explored your options makes it easier to move forward with peace of mind.

Next Steps

If you’ve been told you need a hip replacement but still have questions, getting a second opinion is completely reasonable.

At Dr Oliver Khoo’s clinic, we provide thorough assessments to help you understand your options and make an informed decision.

Consultations available in Griffith and Sydney – Contact us today to book an appointment.

Your hip pain doesn’t have to control your life—let’s find the right solution for you.